TL;DR

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get movie nights delivered free with Prime

• Fast, free delivery on millions of items
• Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
• Member-only deals all year

Start your free Prime trial →Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.Hide

Guillermo Rodriguez, Jimmy Kimmel’s sidekick, has become an unexpected audience favorite on the current season of Dancing With the Stars, despite receiving low judges’ scores. Psychology Today says his appeal may reflect both his perceived authenticity and “basking in reflected glory,” a psychological concept describing fans’ shared sense of a favorite’s success.

Guillermo Rodriguez, Jimmy Kimmel’s longtime sidekick, has emerged as an unexpected audience favorite on the current season of Dancing With the Stars, prompting a Psychology Today article to examine why viewers are rallying behind him. The article points to his perceived authenticity and a social psychology concept called “basking in reflected glory”, while noting that fan votes have kept him in the competition despite low judges’ scores.

Rodriguez is competing with professional dancer Witney Carson. Psychology Today reports that after the pair’s recent samba, the judges awarded them 13 out of 30 points, yet audience voting was sufficient to keep them on the show for another week. The article does not provide vote totals or a comparison with other contestants, so the scale of his support cannot be quantified from the information given.

The analysis describes Rodriguez’s appeal as partly rooted in his established public persona: he moved from working as a security guard to appearing as a comic sidekick on Jimmy Kimmel’s program. The article says viewers appreciate that he does not appear to take himself too seriously and is willing to acknowledge his limitations. After a dance, Rodriguez reportedly opened his shirt to show the words “Dancing 4 The People,” framing the moment as a nod to fan enthusiasm rather than his own dance ability.

Psychology Today also invokes BIRG, short for “basking in reflected glory.” The term describes people’s tendency to feel connected to a favorite’s success and to present that association positively. The article applies the idea to viewers who support Rodriguez as he advances, but this is an interpretation of the voting dynamic, not evidence establishing why individual viewers voted for him.

How Fan Voting Shapes His Run

Rodriguez’s progress highlights the role of audience votes in a competition where judges’ scores and public support can point in different directions. His reported 13 out of 30 for the samba did not prevent him and Carson from returning, illustrating that a contestant’s performance score is not the only factor determining who stays.

The psychology framing offers one possible explanation for the enthusiasm, but it should not be mistaken for a measured account of every fan’s motives. Some viewers may respond to Rodriguez’s humor, familiarity from television, perceived relatability or dance performances; the article does not establish the relative influence of those factors. The broader point is that a contestant can become a focus of audience identification even when judges rank the performance poorly.

That dynamic can also intensify disagreement among fans. Psychology Today notes that supporters of other contestants may fear their favorites will be eliminated as Rodriguez advances. Online criticism and allegations that the show is rigged appear in the article’s account of viewer reactions, but no evidence is presented to substantiate claims of rigging.

From Kimmel Sidekick to Contestant

Rodriguez’s television visibility predates his appearance on Dancing With the Stars. Psychology Today describes his rise from a quirky security guard to an onstage sidekick for Jimmy Kimmel, a path that had already built a following before the dance competition. His current popularity, then, is not presented as a sudden introduction to viewers, but as a new phase for a familiar personality.

The article connects that familiarity with viewers’ interest in people who seem unpolished or vulnerable. It says Rodriguez’s willingness to admit he is not an accomplished dancer may make his success more engaging to viewers. One comment on Deadline’s article, as quoted by Psychology Today, read: “The world needs more Guillermos and especially now!” That comment reflects one reader’s view, not a representative survey of public opinion.

The BIRG concept comes from social psychology research. Psychology Today cites a 1976 study by Robert Cialdini and co-authors on fans’ responses to football-team success, as well as a 1986 study by Snyder, Lassegard and Ford on distancing from group failure. The article uses those ideas to describe how people may associate themselves with a successful favorite and, in some circumstances, distance themselves after a loss.

““Just like everybody else, I’m obsessed with you.””

— Derek Hough, Dancing With the Stars judge, as quoted by Psychology Today

What the Voting Numbers Show

The available account does not give vote totals, the size of Rodriguez’s lead or the voting margin between contestants. It therefore cannot show exactly how much support he received or how his votes compared with those of other couples. It also does not establish that BIRG caused viewers to vote for him; the concept is offered as one possible explanation.

Psychology Today reports accusations online that the competition is rigged, alongside comments from viewers who believe Rodriguez should leave. The article provides no evidence that the show’s voting is manipulated, and the accusations remain unsubstantiated claims. The contestant’s eventual placement and whether his run will continue through the finale are also unresolved in the account.

The Next Elimination and Finale

Rodriguez and Carson are set to return for the next stage of the competition, according to Psychology Today’s account. Their position will depend on the show’s next performances and the combined outcome of its judging and audience-voting process; the article gives no schedule or later results.

The remaining test is whether Rodriguez’s support will carry him further, potentially to the mirror-ball trophy, or whether future performances and voting will end the run. Until results are announced, claims about his likely finish remain speculation. The article’s conclusion is that the competition will show how enduring his audience backing is, not that a particular outcome is assured.

Key Questions

Who is Guillermo Rodriguez on Dancing With the Stars?

Rodriguez is Jimmy Kimmel’s sidekick and a contestant on the current Dancing With the Stars season. He is paired with professional dancer Witney Carson.

Why has Rodriguez become popular with viewers?

Psychology Today suggests viewers may respond to his perceived authenticity, humor and willingness to acknowledge his limits. It also proposes that some fans may share emotionally in a favorite’s success through “basking in reflected glory.” The article does not establish a single cause for his popularity.

What does “basking in reflected glory” mean?

Basking in reflected glory, or BIRG, describes feeling associated with a person or group’s success even when you did not contribute to it. Psychology Today applies the concept to fans who identify with a favorite contestant’s progress.

Did the judges give Rodriguez a high score for his samba?

No. Psychology Today reports that Rodriguez and Carson received 13 out of 30 points for the samba, but audience votes kept them in the competition for another week.

Is there evidence that the show is rigged?

The article mentions online accusations that the show is rigged but provides no evidence supporting them. They should be treated as unsubstantiated claims, not confirmed facts.

Source: psychologytoday.com